CQOD Special Archive
Of Rice and Men
Published under the title “Rice Christians”
by Robert MacColl Adams
Everybody knows what “rice Christians” are, I suppose. People here in the United States have tended to look
down upon the beggarly Chinese (or Indian, or what-not) who would crawl to the mission compound and pretend
to be a convert to Christianity just for a bowlful of boiled rice a day. But it is a strangely hard heart
that will scorn a man for choosing to be a “rice Christian” instead of a no-rice Buddhist, for example... a
strangely hard heart, I say, and doubly strange in a Christian, who might be expected to be glad if a man
has forsaken the worship of Buddha for that of Christ, no matter what the inducement was.
But it is no use, you may say (as I did), to give up worshipping Buddha unless you become a real Christian,
and these rice Christians cared only for the rice: they had not given their hearts to Christ. Perhaps not.
But if not, who is to blame?
The rice Christian should have realized what is involved in being a real Christian; but it would be easier
to condemn his ignorance if he had ever seen real Christians. The rice Christian might be illiterate, but
he knew something of the world. He might even know, in a dim way, that for every rice-doling missionary in
China, there were hundreds and thousands of Christians back in America whose missionary zeal and Christian
love supported the missionary and provided the meager rations of rice he doled out. Can you blame the poor
man with the bowl of rice if he got the impression that being a Christian doesn’t make any very heavy
demands on a person?
Of course, the poor fellow may not have known—and the missionary may have omitted to tell
him—that, for most American Christians, being a Christian is almost entirely external, a matter of
conformity to a certain socially approved pattern of behavior at certain limited times, and that—far
from demanding a man’s heart—American Christianity has a hard time prying him loose from his pocket
change. However, a lot of the beggars did know this: even among the illiterate, the word gets around. And
so the rice Christian may well have thought himself as much a Christian as anyone else.
But surely, you will say, the hypothetical well-informed rice Christian had seen one real Christian, by
anyone’s definition: what about the missionary? All right, what about him? The beggar may simply have
thought of him as an exception. If he really understood the price the missionary was paying for his
Christianity, he also knew about the many “Christians” who declined to pay any such price... indeed, any
price at all. And it is hard to blame the beggar for concluding that devotion is, to say the least, optional
for Christians. More likely, though, he didn’t know about the price. You and I know how badly the missionary
was supported, and how much he gave up. But the beggar saw him as one of the kings of the earth, wealthy
beyond the dreams of avarice (didn’t he have food to give away?), protected by unseen Powers, the darling
of Fortune. Can any of us appreciate, I wonder, how the average American looks to a man who has never had
a full meal in his life?
All four Evangelists record that, when Jesus had fed the five thousand, they were all filled. You and I
might not think much of the chance of stuffing ourselves on dry rye bread and sun-cured herring; but to
the people actually involved, it was an unparalleled miracle—they walked halfway around the Sea of
Galilee in the broiling sun the next day just on the chance of finding this Jesus again. And some of them
did find Him. He knew that they had not followed Him for His teaching, but because of that startling, that
mind-shattering miracle of the full bellies. But He did not scorn them: He only went on to teach them the
difference between a rice Christian and a real one.
Those rice Christians who used to come to our mission stations in China—they may have come only
because of the rice, but they came to the right place, didn’t they? They came to Christ as He was held
out to them, and they were taught there about being real Christians. We don’t have any rice-bearing
missionaries in China any more, but there are still Christians there. Not many, you say. Who knows? And
who knows how many Christians there would be in our own fair land ten years after the rice was cut off?
For we all began as rice Christians, you know. All of us came first because we were hungry—no higher
reason. Even the mushiest rice gruel is better than hunger pangs. Did you come to Him through fear
of Hell? There’s a low motive for you: “Let Jesus Christ save you; following Him is better than an eternity
of torment.” But many a Christian came to Christ first for just that reason. There is energy in even plain
boiled rice. Did you come to Him because you couldn’t carry your load of guilt any more? There’s another
low-level appeal, isn’t it? “Let Jesus Christ bear your burden; following Him is better than total
collapse.” Yet this low-level appeal brought many a Christian to Christ, and still does.
There are vitamins in unpolished rice, unattractive though it is. Did you come to Him because of deficiency
diseases in your soul—no hope, no direction, no purpose in living? What a pitifully low appeal: “Let
Jesus Christ give you a reason for living; following Him is better than suicide.” A low appeal indeed—so
low, in fact, that it reached down to me when (it seemed) nothing else could; and so I, for one, can’t look
down on it.
Well, there are crunchier, flakier, yummier forms of rice. American technology enables rice to be presented
in a variety of forms, not all easily recognized as rice. There’s the golden rice flake of Christian
respectability: here we are in our proper place of service and testimony to the community; how good it is
to know that we are on God’s side! There’s the dainty rice puff of Christian intellectuality: we love those
“studies” which require of us only that slight degree of intellectual effort which is a pleasure; how good
it is to be learning to understand God! And there’s the fragile rice crispy of Christian fellowship: in this
finest of all forms of togetherness there is only the slightest touch of snobbery, sometimes; and the glow
we get from being with God’s family may last for hours.
Now there is some real nourishment in these things, even if they have a way of starting you to wondering
about lunch at about 10:30 A.M. But all rice, all grain, all food, is like that. They are only the “meat
which perisheth”, after all—good enough to bring us to Jesus Christ, but not good enough to sustain
us long without Him. And the yummiest, crunchiest, nuttiest form of rice now being offered to people is,
I think, the notion that Christianity is fun: “Become a Christian and all your troubles are over”, is the
general idea. The Christian life is presented as one long, sweet song, a triumphal procession of jolly
associations, marvelous sessions of prayer and study, happy-happy worship services, the grandest conquest
over sin and weakness and error, a successful avoidance of all the snares of the world without missing any
of its joys. Everything is great, everything is going to be great from here on in.
Well, we all began as rice Christians, and not many of us can be sure, even yet, that the rice means
absolutely nothing to us. It is not for one rice Christian to say that another cannot be sincere, or that
the Lord Jesus may not draw a man to Himself by any means that will serve His purpose. And there is joy in
belonging to Him: it is a real joy, a happiness beyond anything the world can give. Looking back, I can see
that I was never really happy before I met Him; looking forward, I know that there can be no happiness
without Him again, ever again. And I wouldn’t want any prospective Christian not to know this, or not to
realize that our final destiny is complete happiness.
But being a Christian here and now is not all cokes and bowling. In coming to know Jesus, you have come to
know yourself, too: naturally, this is more pleasant for some than for others, but to see yourself as you
really are can never be entirely pleasant. And when a Christian fails at something he ought to have done,
it isn’t just the failure that hurts—there is also the knowledge that he has let Jesus down. And
those little shortcomings of ours, that used to matter so little, compared with the glaring faults of others:
we know now that our temper, or our gloom, or our selfishness, reflects on Jesus; and knowing that people
are judging your Lord by you is not always a joyous thought to live with. Even the growing up to His measure
is hard on a man: we have so little aptitude for such a transformation that it always means conflict, and
often rebellion. And temptations hurt as they never did before: not just in the conscience, but in the heart.
The assaults of temptation are not on our prudence now, or even on our morals, but on the love for Jesus.
His love for us has made Him quite defenseless against our hurting Him, and so temptation is no longer an
urge to do a bad thing but an urge to hurt a loving Person.
No, being a real Christian isn’t all fun, and don’t tell anyone it is. You come for the rice, and it’s good...
as far as it goes. But it doesn’t last forever. No matter what kind of rice brought you to Jesus, it won’t
last. If you have really come to Him, that doesn’t matter. But if you haven’t, you will saunter up to the
mission station one day, and the door will be shut. And there you will be with your empty bowl,
seeing—just your helpless self staring at the empty place in you where Jesus wasn’t allowed to come.
Yes, we all started as rice Christians. But if all you have found is advantage, whether it is fun or profit
or security, then you haven’t started following Him yet. His way is the way of the Cross. The world can be
very hard on those it hates. If it is not hard on you, perhaps it sees nothing in you to hate. But then it
doesn’t see Jesus in you, for it hates Jesus with an undying hatred. While your way is still all fun, all
easy, all jolly, it is only your way: when you turn from it to follow His way, it will cost. It may cost
you everything you have. That is what it cost Him.
2 February, 1962
I hope you are enjoying the CQOD Special Archive. These are placed here as a
service to the friends of CQOD.
Here are some other important links to help you get around:
CQOD for today
CQOD on the go!
Use our double opt-in listserve to receive CQOD by email
CQOD daily index
All monthly archives
What’s New on CQOD
Search CQOD (or see below)
Facebook CQOD Fan Page
Follow CQOD on Twitter
CQOD on the Web
CQOD Liturgical Calendar
Mere Christianity: a conversation
Simple Songs for Psalms
Quotations Bible Study
Jonah: a miracle play
Ruth: a play
Also visit these organizations:
↑ Grab this Headline Animator